Focusing with a modified Hartmann mask (2 slit mask)

You can find an optimised version here

The Hartmann mask is a simple and cheap tool to focus a telescope for photography. Take a cardboard disk with the diameter of the telescope's optic, cut two (or three) holes in it and place it in front of the telescope. If the telescope is out of focus then two stars in a certain distance of each other are seen for any single star. When approaching focus the distance of the two star images decreases until they meet in the focus and only single stars can be seen. This method is described for example by Jerry Lodriguss .

What sounds to be very easy is quite tricky in practice. Near the focus the two star images melt to an oblong star. The nearer the focus the more difficult it is to decide whether the star image is still oblong or round. Bad seeing makes the whole thing even worse. When you see that the star image becomes oblong again then you know that you just passed the focus. Now try again and don't forget the hystheresis when focussing with a SCT. Some smart people thought of improvements. Ron Wodaski describes a modification of the Hartmann mask that uses two triangular holes instead of the round holes. Since one of the triangular holes is rotated 60 degrees the star image in the focus shows six spikes. Antonio Fernandez describes and illusrtrates this method nicely.

The pictures of Antonio Fernandez show that the difference of the star images of "nearly in focus" and "in focus" is very small and again difficult to determine, especially with bad seeing. But the fact that the shape of the holes determines the shape of the star image at the focus lead me to the idea to use a vertical and a horizontal slit instead of the two triangular or round holes. I expected to see a cross at the focus. I closed the openings in my Hartmann mask with tape and cut two slits in it as can be seen on the left.

The next clear night proved that this method works. It is easy to determine in advance (!) when the focus will be reached. That is when the vertical line cuts the horizontal line exactly in the middle. The time consuming procedure to find the focus with often turning the focusser too far came to an end. The three steps during focussing are illustrated above. At the left the focus is far away. In the middle the focus is quite near, and at the right the cross of a perfectly focussed star can be seen. With this simple and precise method I solved my focussing problems.

ADDENDUM:

I used the modified Hartmann mask since several months successfully and found another interesting feature. I can check at any time whether the focus has moved or not by simply placing the mask in front of the telescope. Especially at the beginning of the night the focus will shift with the drop in temperatures. If one of the lines does no longer cut the other one exctly in the middle adjusting the focus is necessary. Since I am photographing with a CCTV-camera I can even check and adjust the focus during exposing a series of frames. That takes only a few seconds and the handfull of frames that have been impacted can easily be sorted out afterwards.



LAST BUT NOT LEAST:

This is a contrast adjusted single image where the mask was left accidentally on the telescope . . .

The image was taken with the Atik CCD camera and shows NGC 7331.



Can this slit mask be improved further? Yes, it can as you can see here.

 

Back